← all stories

After the Web · Era 4 · Dot-coms and the crash

1999–2008IPO on NYSE · 2004

Salesforce

Salesforce is a company that in 1999 in San Francisco began selling software for sales departments not in a box but as a subscription through the browser, under the slogan \"No Software.\" By its IPO in 2004 it had about 9,800 customers and $96 million in annual revenue, and it showed its first profit only in its fourth year of sales. It remained an independent public company.

Founders Marc Benioff · Parker Harris · David Moellenhoff
Domains salesforce.com
saassubscriptioncrmplatform

In brief

Salesforce is a company founded in February 1999 by former Oracle senior vice president Marc Benioff together with the programmers Parker Harris and David Moellenhoff. It sold its sales-tracking software not as a license with an installation but as a subscription through the browser, presented this as the end of software, and registered the slogan as a trademark. By its IPO in June 2004 it had about 9,800 customers and $96 million in annual revenue, but it showed its first profit only in the year that ended in January 2004.

How it started (the founders)

Benioff worked at Oracle from 1986 to 1999, his last title being senior vice president. Harris and Moellenhoff had run Left Coast Software together since 1996, a small Java consulting firm; by the time Salesforce was founded, Harris held the post of vice president there and Moellenhoff that of president. The result was a typical pairing: a salesman with the market in his head and two technical people who knew how to build web applications. The company was incorporated in Delaware in February 1999.

The money came quickly and in small pieces. In April 1999 the first series of shares went for $0.02 a share, for $517,000, together with a convertible loan of $62,875 from Benioff himself; in June 1999 came $3.8 million, in November $13.2 million, and from March 2000 to June 2001 another $46.9 million, about $64.4 million in all before the IPO. Among the major shareholders at the IPO, Halsey Minor (10.0%) is named; a director since March 1999 was the venture investor Magdalena Yesil.

Larry Ellison's role in this is murky in the documents. In June 2000 Techdirt wrote that Benioff had earlier invited Ellison to join the board and asked him to invest $2 million of his own money, and was now asking him to leave; Business Insider later repeated the same amount. But the 2004 IPO prospectus does not mention Ellison at all, neither among the directors nor among the major holders. See "Legend vs. the record."

Year-by-year timeline

Lesser-known but significant facts

  1. Cash flow arrived before profit. In FY2003 the company was still losing $9.7 million, but operating cash flow was positive ($5.2 million): customers paid in advance under non-cancelable 12–24-month contracts, and deferred revenue grew from $7.1 million to $19.2 million in a year.
  2. The advertising bill for the launch. In FY2001 marketing, above all advertising, made up 62% of all sales and marketing expenses, and in FY2002 47%; the FY2001 loss ($31.7 million) was 5.8 times revenue ($5.4 million).
  3. Even in 2004 the IPO prospectus called the market unproven. The company that later became the symbol of the cloud cautioned in its own prospectus that the market might never develop at all.
  4. Churn is not disclosed in the prospectus. There is no churn figure in either the S-1 or the 10-K for FY2005: there is only a caveat that it is higher among small customers (<200 employees).
  5. An interview in the New York Times made it into the prospectus's risk factors. A long piece on Benioff came out on 2004-05-09, during the quiet period before the IPO; the prospectus notes the risk of premature promotion of the offering (gun jumping): if the publicity were judged a violation, the company could be required to buy back the shares it had sold.

Legend vs. the record

The first growth lever

The first lever was not the product but the packaging and the price of entry. On the 2001 home page: the first five seats free for a year, then $50 per seat per month, no hardware and no installation, phone number 1-800-NO-SOFTWARE. The customer base grew like this: about 1,500 customers in FY2001, 3,500 in FY2002, 5,700 in FY2003, 8,700 in FY2004, and 13,900 in FY2005. Revenue meanwhile grew 4.1 times in FY2002, then 2.3, 1.9, and 1.8 times.

This came at a high cost: marketing, above all advertising, made up 62% of sales and marketing expenses in FY2001, and sales and marketing together ate up 66% of revenue in FY2003 and 57% in FY2004. The money was recouped through 12–24-month contracts, non-cancelable and paid in advance. The second lever was the platform: sforce (2003), AppExchange (2005), and Force.com (2007) turned customers and third-party developers into an ecosystem.

The paired story

Parallels today (projects from the catalog)

What a builder can take from this in 2026

  1. Name an enemy, not a category. "No Software" is not a description of the product but a contrast; it was registered as a trademark and spelled out in the phone number.
  2. Offer free entry, but with a timer. Five seats for 12 months and $50 for each additional one is a model that today would be called freemium, but with a predictable end to the free period.
  3. Payment up front matters more than profit. 12–24-month contracts and money up front produced positive cash flow a year before profit; track deferred revenue, not just net income.
  4. Do not confuse noise with cause. The stunt at a competitor's conference is what people remember, but marketing, above all advertising, made up 62% of sales and marketing expenses in FY2001; for you, noise without a budget will not replace a channel.
  5. Open up the platform once the core is holding. sforce, AppExchange, and Force.com came in the 5th to 9th years, when there were already more than 5,700 customers.

Discrepancies and what we could not verify

Sources (primary first)

Internet History Keeper

Every historical dossier here is free and open, and it will stay that way. If you want the series to keep going (new dossiers, checks against primary sources, the English edition), support it with a subscription for $9.90 a month. It is support, not access, and you can cancel at any time.

Become a keeper — $9.90 a month →

The same thing, about today

The same breakdowns, but of projects launching right now: what the product is, where the first users came from, how they charge. The card is free, the full dossier is $5 (the dossier itself is written in Russian).

Browse the dossier catalog →